HS2

From ScienceForSustainability
Revision as of 10:23, 4 September 2020 by Sisussman (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

There has been a lot of controversy about the British HS2 high speed rail project, with claims that it's elitist, destructive of wildlife, unnecessary, etc.

Wildlife champion Chris Packham has been prominently involved in the campaign against it.

This Twitter thread by @GarethDennis responds to some of the objections raised to HS2.


Greens for HS2 (@Greens4HS2 on twitter) produced this commentary (with diagrams not included in the excerpt below)

We keep coming across some misunderstandings from Greens about what #HS2 is, where it goes , what it's for and how much it costs. So here's a thread dealing with a few.

Let's start with where it goes. "Just 20 minutes quicker to Birmingham", people say. Nope: on the day that #HS2 starts, in 2029, its trains will also serve Liverpool, Manchester and Glasgow.

The trains run on the new railway between London and Birmingham, then continue their journeys on the existing railway - which will be being upgraded in the meantime to smooth things out. This is just like French TGVs do.

A couple of years later, the new Euston station will open and more trains can run: 3 per hour to B'ham and Manchester as well as other services.

And they'll be much faster than now: Birmingham 32 mins quicker at just 49 mins; Liverpool 40 mins quicker; Manchester eventually 1 hour quicker at 1hr 7 mins; Glasgow eventually 50 mins quicker.

When the other part of HS2 is built - "Phase 2b" to Manchester, Leeds and York - a whole slew of new services will run. New trains to Sheffield, Leeds, York, Newcastle and Edinburgh.

And of course, these new trains replace the express trains on the existing network, so that it's freed up for much better regional and local services. This gives thousands of people in and around Birmingham, Manchester and Leeds the opportunity to use train and ditch the car.

So it's not just a fast line to Birmingham - it's equivalent to a reboot of the whole railway network in the Midlands / North - the groundwork for Midlands Connect Rail and Northern Powerhouse Rail. Next up - how much it's going to cost and could it fund the NHS instead....


Oakervee review Dec 2019

Comment in Rail magazine